MEMBER LOGIN
email

password

forgot password?
     
 
SIGN UP FOR FANZAK
 
INVITED TO FANZAK?
     

yerblues 3 Comments 2386 Read Feb 02, 2009


Now that the 2008 NFL Season is over, concluding with one of the most memorable Super Bowls of all time, it is time to look back and see who are the legends on the field.  For this list, I'm going to select the ten players who played during the 2008 I feel have the best shot of being first ballot Hall of Famers when they retire, in order of likelihood.

1. Brett Favre (QB, New York Jets): What career passing doesn't this guy have? Most passing yards, completions, attempts, touchdowns, interceptions (?!). He also has that insane consecutive games started streak.  He won a Super Bowl in 1997. Blessed with a rifle arm and impressive improvisational skills, Favre is one of the legends of the game.

2. Tom Brady (QB, New England Patriots): Brady is the epitome of cool under pressure, picking apart defenses. He won three Super Bowls early in his career and lead his team to a perfect record in 2007 only to be stopped in the Super Bowl by the New York Giants (2008). That same year, he broke the single-season record for touchdown passes.

3. Peyton Manning (QB, Indianapolis Colts): Though, like Brady, he's still a relatively young player, Manning already has the seventh most career passing yards and fourth most touchdown passes. Like Favre, he has been named league MVP three times, and led his team to a Super Bowl victory in 2007. He is the ultimate field general, an offensive coordinator who just happens to play QB.

4. Junior Seau (LB, New England Patriots): This six-time first-team AllPro has had a long and distinguished career.  Until the arrival of Ray Lewis, he was the most feared LB in the game. He made it to two Super Bowls (1995 & 2008), but was on the losing squad both times.

5. Ray Lewis (LB, Baltimore Ravens): This fierce tackler, seemingly able to cover the entire length of the field, has long been the emotional leader of the Ravens, helping to lead them to their only Super Bowl victory (2001). Like Seau, he is a six-time first-team AllPro.

6. LaDanian Tomlinson (RB, San Diego Chargers): Though in the last two postseasons he has been unable to play, this man's talent cannot be questioned. Emerging as the most versatile RB since Marshall Faulk and the most exciting since Barry Sanders, he has managed to become the fourteenth all-time leading rusher in yardage and second in touchdowns. Keep in mind this was only his eighth season. In his staggering 2006 campaign, he rushed for 28 touchdowns.

7. Adam Vinatieri (K, Indianapolis Colts): What is a kicker doing on this list? Well, Vinatieri has kicked four of the most clutch field goals in NFL history, and has been a crucial component to four Super Bowl championship teams.

8. Derrick Brooks (LB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers): Ten years ago, Brooks, along with Warren Sapp, spearheaded the league's most feared defensive strike force. He is a five-time first-team AllPro.

9. Tony Gonzalez (TE, Kansas City Chiefs): Emerging as the greatest TE since Shannon Sharpe, Gonzalez has long been the Chiefs' primary target in the passing game. Even though he is a TE, he has the ninth most receptions in NFL history.

10. Kurt Warner (QB, Arizona Cardinals): He was the inspiration for this list because of the debates triggered by his inspirational rags-to-riches-to-rags-to-riches career arc. Even before these last two seasons, I've always maintained Warner was a Hall of Fame QB. He came from out of nowhere to win league MVP and a Super Bowl in 1999/2000.  He has since been to two more Super Bowls, and now has the three most prolific passing games in Super Bowl history.

Hopefully this list will generate some conversation. Since the Hall of Fame tends to privilege "glamor" position players like quaterbacks, running backs, and wide receivers, there are probably some notable offensive linemen and defensive players that I've overlooked.  Also, there are several notable wide receivers that didn't quite make the cut here, most notably Terrell Owens, Marvin Harrison, Randy Moss, Isaac Bruce, and Torry Holt. Owens, of all these receivers, has the best chance of making it, as a player (especially considering his worthy effort in 2005's Super Bowl), but his off-field and locker room theatrics will hurt him. Ditto Randy Moss (who has yet to really dazzle big time in the playoffs). Isaac Bruce and Torry Holt, both worthy, sort of cancel each other out (though, at this point, Isaac Bruce has the edge). Marvin Harrison is particularly puzzling because for all his impressive statistics, he has proven to be incredibly soft in the playoffs. Hines Ward, whose career numbers aren't as impressive as these guys, has a shot because of his prominent role in two Super Bowl championships. Edgerrin James is another player who I think is on the bubble. An early career knee injury reduced him from being a dazzling runner into a sturdy pounder in the mold of Jerome Bettis.  But, unless he was actually Bettis, I'm not sure this will get him into the Hall. And though Ben Roethlisberger is in elite company now with this two Super Bowl wins, it is simply too early in his career to crown him just yet.

As you can probably tell, many of these picks are included because they were part of Super Bowl championship teams. Should this elevate certain players over those who might not have performed well during the postseason but who, nonetheless, had great careers?

Tags:
LaDanian Tomlinson, Kurt Warner, Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, NFL Hall of Fame, NCAA FB , Kansas (NCAA FB), NCAA FB , Indiana (NCAA FB), NCAA FB , Marshall (NCAA FB), NCAA FB , Arizona (NCAA FB), NCAA FB , San Diego (NCAA FB)

Share This Story: Yahoo Blogmarks Del.icio.us Google Spurl Furl Live
Digg
3 Responses to 'Legends of the Game'
Justin says on Tuesday, February 3rd at 4:02pm

I would say that you have left off a few people. I would not put Kurt Warner on this list. Heinz Ward is questionable, Big Ben needs a few more years to determine where he stands but the two players who I unquestionably think that should be on the list are Ed Reed and Troy Polomolu.

Zapsnap says on Tuesday, February 3rd at 1:14am

Is Roethisberger a hall of famer? I am not so sure yet. Both years that Piitsburgh has won, it has been the defense. If Trent Dilfer won two Super Bowls with the Baltimore defense, would he be a hall of famer?

Ok, so comparing Ben to Trent Dilfer is going a little overboard, but I don't think he cracks the top 10.

SixBurgh says on Tuesday, February 3rd at 1:14am

You forgot Ben Roethlisberger.



Leave a Reply










Biography
Brian Flota is a professor of English (specializing in American literature) at a university in the state of Oklahoma. He was born in Southern Illinois during the Gerald Ford administration, but grew up in Southern California's Inland Empire. His favorite athletes are the venerable contact hitter Wade Boggs and the slugging running back John Riggins. He spent all of his allowance money on baseball cards in the late 1980s and early 1990s that are now worth nothing. In his early thirties, he was a standout utility player on Arlington, Virginia's powerhouse co-ed softball squad The Pubfish, providing him with all the insight he would ever need to know about the panacea of professional athletics. He often holds less-than-popular opinions about sports' greatest controversies, but never takes them too seriously.

Fanzak Writers
The Sports Lecture
by Ryan White

Little Giants Big on Gender
Posted 13 weeks ago.
The Sports Orphan
by Justin Brindger

Oh I Wish I was a Professional Baseball Player
Posted 24 weeks ago.
It's All Over But The Crying
by Andrew Lovell

NFL week nine picks
Posted 18 weeks ago.
The Tailgate
by Shae Cronin

Matt Barkley: The Poster Boy Potential
Posted 24 weeks ago.
The Forecheck
by Brendan Coyle

Pittsburgh Penguins are the Stanley Cup Champions.
Posted 39 weeks ago.